5.0 out of 5 stars These Minnows Turned My Kittens Into Oceanic Criminals

M. · June 16, 2025

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } Buyers beware: these freeze-dried minnows are not just treats — they are a gateway snack to feline felonies.I bought these thinking, "Oh how cute, a healthy little snack for my sweet baby kittens." What I actually purchased was the catalyst to a full-blown Ocean's Eleven-style heist.My household has two masterminds-in-fur: one older cat with Olympic-level vertical jumps, and a younger kitten who could probably crack a biometric safe with a twist-tie and three seconds. Together? Unstoppable.I came home from the simple task of dropping off my kids at school — just 20 minutes tops — and walked into what I can only describe as Minnow Mayhem™. The older cat had scaled the high kitchen cabinets (where we thought the treats were safely hidden), then yeeted the bag down like some sort of loot drop to his partner in crime. My younger kitten, already waiting like a furry gremlin, had the bag ripped open in a time span that made me question the laws of physics.In the 15 steps it took for me to reach the kitchen, the job was done. The bag was open. The minnows were being inhaled. And me? I made the mistake of trying to intervene.That's when my younger kitten unlocked their final form: Feral Flash™. I reached for the bag and suddenly — BAM — a blur of paws, a flurry of crunches, and then… silence. Except for the sound of tiny, dried fish raining across my floor like a seafood apocalypse.My kitchen looked like Poseidon's pantry exploded.So yes — five stars. Absolutely delicious, apparently. But guard these with your life. Store them in a biometric safe. Possibly a bank vault. Because once your cats get a taste, they will stop at nothing. They will find them. They will open them. And they will eat them like furry piranhas at a Vegas buffet.Don’t be like me. Protect yourself. Protect your minnows.

5.0 out of 5 stars Kitten approved! May not be for picky cats

J. · June 17, 2025

I bought the minnows for my 10 month old kitten. I wanted these to fulfill his needs for his hunting instincts and play. I toss one over, he darts to chase it. He'll play with it and chew it, then devour the rest. Very crunchy, but he loves it! He's very energetic and playful, so this is a perfect addition for his routine. I tried to feed some to our 2 other adult cats, but they showed no interest. So keep in mind that this may not be for every kitty! But overall, great healthy treats for cats!

5.0 out of 5 stars They are real organs, wet inside, might not be for everyone

F. · June 1, 2025

Just got these. For anyone wondering, they are real organs. They were way too big for my kitten, so I had to chop them up. He really loves freeze dried treats (I use them as toppers for his food). He loves his minnows and he absolutely loved this. I did have to cut them up. I did it with my hands, though, and they are a bit wet on the inside, so I suggest cutting them with a knife. The only downside is the bag is really small and there aren't many inside - but I found the bigger bag for the dog treats is exactly the same and worth the cost. We have a corgi too, so I'll have to see if he likes them as well when the rest of my family are back from camping. I like to get treats they can share.

5.0 out of 5 stars My cats know a premium product when they smell it!

H. · June 13, 2025

This brand of treats is superior to other brands, including the economy pack I bought at my local pet store. Somehow this brand makes the minnow tender rather than chewy and sinuous. But the most important factor for my picky kitties is the flavor. These must smell better too because they don't reject them like they reject bulk bags of dried minnows. It's definitely a premium product and my cats seem to know it!

4.0 out of 5 stars Worth the try in my opinion! - Minnows

J.H. · June 15, 2025

1 out of my 5 loved the minnows! I have 2 kittens going to new homes ( 1 of those is the one that **loves** the minnows) and 3 adult cats. The 1 kitten is crazy about them! The rest (1 kitten and 3 adults) are not too sure... I would reccomend these as long as A) it's affordable to you. Or B) you have a friend/family/neighbor to give them as a 'kitty present' *just* in case your own kitty doesn't take to them. If they do, you won't be disappointed! I think its worth the try to be honest. I just held them and used my thumb nail to break them into 1/3 or 1/4 (depending on size). Unless your kitty is fully grown and sorta wild, I would reccomend breaking them up. Plus it releases a different smell that may entice them. I gave a 4 star because it's my first night trying them and the reaction that we recieved from the 1 kitten was well worth the money! Who knows.. the others may beg for them tomorrow!

5.0 out of 5 stars My cat’s favorite treat

M. · May 24, 2025

Every morning before I leave the house, my cat eagerly waits in the kitchen for his daily Vital Essentials Minnow. It’s become our little ritual, and he absolutely looks forward to it. These treats are made from a single ingredient…whole freeze-dried minnows which means they’re free from fillers, grains, and artificial additives. I feel great knowing I’m giving him something natural and healthy.  The treats are lightweight and not greasy, making them easy to handle. Plus, they don’t have a strong odor, which is a bonus for me. My cat loves the crunch, and I appreciate that they’re high in protein and support his overall health. It’s clear these are a hit in our household, and I’ll definitely continue to keep them stocked!

5.0 out of 5 stars Favorite cat treats!

k.h. · June 13, 2025

My cats love there’s treats!! They are their favorite! I get two packs shipped to me every month! I typically cut the hearts in half depending on size. As soon as I open the drawer in where the treats are kept the cats, know “time for chicky hearts” and they always come running!! Highly recommended.

Both my cats LOVE these treats

L. · January 3, 2024

(function() { P.when('cr-A', 'ready').execute(function(A) { if(typeof A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel === 'function') { A.toggleExpanderAriaLabel('review_text_read_more', 'Read more of this review', 'Read less of this review'); } }); })(); .review-text-read-more-expander:focus-visible { outline: 2px solid #2162a1; outline-offset: 2px; border-radius: 5px; } I gave my 2 cats this for the first time last week. At first they were very sceptical of the treats as they’ve never had them before but both of them LOVED it after staring at it for a bit. I am going to cut each treat in 2 from now on though (there are not a lot in the packaging) to try to make them last longer. This is not a big deal at all considering how big the treats are. I WILL be purchasing this again.

Cat treat.

N.M. · May 13, 2024

Way better ingredients than the garbage cat treats. I use it as a topper for my wet food and the cats loved it. Even my picky one!

Best Omega 3 solution in a treat

D.W. · June 17, 2025

Both my cat and dog love these treats. It’s pricey but worth it. I got them because of their dander and I thought I was imagining it but nope - their coats are shiny and almost dander free after 3 days of one treat/ day. I have to break the little minnow up for my cat but my dog just eats it whole. Will continue to use!

Much too expensive

T. · February 25, 2024

The product itself is fine, though there are hardly any pieces of heart for the price. Might be worth it for around 300 rupees and that would still be expensive -- just check with your local butcher

YES!!

b. · May 24, 2024

My cats loved it! To bad it expires after 30 days tho